Regional Governance: Thai Style
by Bill Dodge
December 16, 2011
practices governance with some unusual twists, some of which offer intriguing models for regional governance in the states. Kingdom of Thailand
During my visit,
was struggling with massive flooding. I monitored the interactions among national, province, and local governments during the disaster. Moreover, I spent time with flood refugees in Pattaya, a city renown for sun and sex south of Thailand . Bangkok
The Thai people have suffered through 16 constitutions, usually triggered by governance crises or military coups. Most of the constitutions make only small changes in the basic government structure, but each redistributes political and economic clout among the traditional powers -- old families, the military, and the royal family -- often with little consideration of citizen desires. Interestingly, the current King has played a role in resolving some governance crises, facilitating peaceful leadership changes between political parties and avoiding the threat of military coups, and yet more constitutions.
As one of the “Asian tigers”,
enjoyed rapid growth through the second half of the last century. However, it suffered its own crisis of overdevelopment in the 1990s. As a result, some economic enterprises owned by the traditional powers were purchased or displaced by international firms, whose logos are now ubiquitous nationwide. Newer roads, often at less than interstate quality, have been built to connect rural farmlands to urban centers. Thailand
Chao Phraya River also channels monsoon waters from the northern rice fields through the city to the . When flooding occurs, it can shut down factories for weeks, relocate families for months. Yet the positive, hospitable spirit that drives the Thai people prevails. Loy Kratong, ironically the festival of the spirit of the waters, was still celebrated with all-night revelry, in the midst of the flooding. Gulf of Thailand
The metropolis of greater
, one of 76 provinces country wide, is governed by the Bangkok Metropolitan Administration (BMA), a creature of the national government. It has an elected chief executive, the Governor of Bangkok, and an elected 57 member Bangkok Metropolitan Council. It is authorized to prepare regional plans and deliver road, transit, waste management, housing, security, and environmental services, but often shares these and other authorities with national and local governments. Bangkok
These sharing arrangements were severely strained by the flooding, resulting in running conflicts between the national government’s flood control organization, the Flood Relief Operations Center (FROC), and the BMA. The Prime Minister and Governor of Bangkok, two of only three directly elected executives in Thailand, carried on a daily war of words and threatened actions in the press. To add to the volatility, neighborhood districts (of which there are 50 in the
region) often felt left out of decisions to control flooding, and periodically engaged in guerilla activities, such as illegally opening flood gates. Bangkok
What can we learn about regional governance from
? The national government has empowered regional governance in the Thailand region, through the BMA, and at times provided funding, to plan and implement major transportation and other regional projects. As a result of the current flooding, the BMA is also a key player in designing and providing the improved flood control systems required to protect Bangkok against future flooding. Whereas its actions might not match the boldness or rapid implementation of Chinese provinces, many of the infrastructure projects are impressive. And protecting the region against future flooding would be monumental. Bangkok
Whereas public comment and criticism of government appears to be a national pastime, public involvement in decision-making still appears to be dominated by the traditional powers. However, major public demonstrations influenced the drafting of the most recent constitution, resulting in provisions supporting public participation. In addition, the Governor of Bangkok and the Bangkok Metropolitan Council are directly-elected. Only time will tell if actions like these will foster greater civic engagement at regional and other levels of governance.
The intriguing “wild card” is the role of the King in resolving governance crises. Whereas this is partially related to the respect that the people have for the current King, the threat of royal family intervention does influence the behavior of political parties. For better or worse, that threat has probably faded, due to the advancing age of the current King and mixed reviews of the crown Prince. Lacking a king, could regions in the states empower individuals or groups of individuals to help bring warring local factions together to take bold regional actions? Maybe a committee composed of regional senior statespeople. When I lived in the
region, for example, Fred Rogers and various Steelers, Pirates, and Penguins could play that role. Pittsburgh
Again, only impressions of a short-term traveler overseas, and a battered regionalist at home, but food for thought for future columns.
Bill Dodge is looking for a few good regions that are interested in designing regional charters to strengthen their capacity to take bold actions to address tough common challenges. He is the former Executive Director of the National Association of Regional Councils, author of Regional Excellence, and is writing a new book on regional charters. WilliamRDodge@aol.com